Tuesday, January 28, 2014

Free public transit in Tallinn

In Salem, our farebox revenue is only about 12% anyway, and a good chunk is wasted on the machinery for fares.
This system with swipe cards for residents makes a lot of sense.

Free public transit in Tallinn is a hit with riders but yields unexpected results | Citiscope

TALLINN, Estonia — Last January, Tallinn, the capital city of Estonia, did something that no other city its size had done before: It made all public transit in the city free for residents.

City officials made some bold predictions about what would result. There would be a flood of new passengers on Tallinn's buses and trams — as many as 20 percent more riders. Carbon emissions would decline substantially as drivers left their cars at home and rode transit instead. And low-income residents would gain new access to jobs that they previously couldn't get to. As Mayor Edgar Savisaar likes to say, zeroing out commuting costs was for some people as good as receiving a 13th month of salary.

One year later, this city of 430,000 people has firmly established itself as the leader of a budding international free-transit movement. Tallinn has hosted two conferences for city officials, researchers and journalists from across Europe to discuss the idea. The city has an English-language website devoted to its experiment. And promotional materials have proclaimed Tallinn the "capital of free public transport."

The idea has been very popular with Tallinners. In an opinion poll, nine out of ten people said they were happy with how it's going. Pille Saks is one of them. "I like free ride," says Saks, a 29 year-old secretary who goes to work by bus. "I have a car, but I don't like to drive with it, especially in the winter when there is a lot of snow and roads are icy."

Different reads on ridership

What's less clear on the first anniversary of free transit in Tallinn is whether it has actually changed commuting behavior all that much.

Mayor Savisaar says it has. He points to numbers from early last year, showing that traffic on the biggest crossroads had decreased by 14 percent compared to a week shortly before the policy started. He has also cited substantial increases in transit riders. "We are frequently asked … why we are offering free-of-charge public transport," Savisaar told a gathering of officials from Europe and China in August. "It is actually more appropriate to ask why most cities in the world still don't."

But researchers at the Royal Institute of Technology in Sweden who are evaluating the program found more modest results. They calculated an increase in passenger demand of just 3 percent — and attributed most of that gain to other factors, such as service improvements and new priority lanes for buses. In their analysis, free pricing accounted for increased demand of only 1.2 percent.

What's more, they found that traffic speeds in Tallinn had not changed — a sign that drivers were not shifting over to riding transit as intended. Actually, the researchers said, if any modal shift is happening, it's that some people are walking less and riding transit more. Their study notes criticisms of free transit as a "second-best pricing scheme" for discouraging automobile use, less effective than increasing the price of parking, gasoline or using the roads.

However, the researchers did find evidence of social benefits in the form of improved access to the city. Of all the districts in Tallinn, transit ridership jumped the most in Lasnamäe, a densely populated area with high unemployment and a large ethnic minority population of Russians. In Lasnamäe, transit ridership increased by 10 percent.

Experiments around the world

Tallinn isn't the first city to experiment with free transit. Across Europe, a number of smaller cities have done it, dating back to the late 1990s. Templin, Germany was one. In France, there was the city of Châteauroux and Aubagne and some surrounding municipalities. Ridership in all of those places increased substantially when fares went away.

The most closely watched was Hasselt, Belgium. After Hasselt made its buses free in 1997, ridership increased more than tenfold. Ultimately, that wasn't sustainable. Facing budget problems last year, Hasselt reintroduced fares of €0.60, although young people, seniors and those receiving public benefits can still ride for free.

Targeted free ridership of the sort Hasselt has got now is much more common around the world. Many cities and college towns in the United States have free "circulator" buses on downtown or campus routes. Singapore is experimenting with free train rides early in the morning to relieve crowding during the morning rush hour. And Chengdu, China has offered a mix of all these perks: free rides for seniors, free rides on 44 central bus lines and free rides from 5 am to 7 am.

What sets Tallinn's experiment apart is its size and Tallinn's status as a European capital. As the birthplace of Skype and online voting, Tallinn also has a reputation for innovation. So there's a feeling, at least among advocates of the idea, that if free transit can work here, maybe it can work in other large cities.

Joining the movement

The Social Democrats, an opposition party, first floated the idea of free transit in Tallinn in 2005. It wasn't taken seriously at first. But later, a former mayor, Hardo Aasmäe, brought up the idea again in a debate in the office of a newspaper. That was noticed by deputy mayor Taavi Aas, who thought it was worth developing further. A 2010 survey of transit riders offered more encouragement: 49 percent of respondents expressed dissatisfaction with fares, more than twice the number who complained about crowding and frequency of service.

There was money available to invest. The construction of public water and sewer infrastructure was about to end, so it was possible to finance public transport with funds that previously had gone into construction. The merger of two municipal transit companies, one that ran the buses and the other the trams and trolleybuses, also saved some money.

Mayor Savisaar unveiled the idea to make public transport free in the beginning of 2012. Savisaar said it would relieve traffic jams and reduce the number of accidents. "And what's most important," he explained, "free ride will provide better access to public transport to families in economically difficult situations."

Opponents called the idea stupid. Some said the money would be better spent on building new kindergartens. Others said if there was no charge then homeless people would ride buses all day and make travel uncomfortable for everyone else.

The city administration put the question to a referendum conducted among Tallinn residents. Turnout in the election was light, but 76 percent of those who did vote said yes to free public transport.

The plan took effect January 1, 2013. Tourists still have to pay €1.60 to ride. But for Tallinn residents, a deposit of €2 gets a smart card that allows limitless travel within the city. Residents do need to swipe the card over a reader when boarding and exiting buses and trams. They also must carry an identification card proving that they are a registered resident of Tallinn.

Replenishing lost revenues

The registered resident part is crucial to how Tallinn is paying for all of this. Before, there were 40,000 unregistered residents of Tallinn, meaning that they lived in the city but were paying taxes to another town where they had previously lived. Now, free transit is an incentive for those people to register and get on Tallinn's tax rolls.

Triin Rannar is one of them. She moved from eastern Estonia to Tallinn a year ago, and rides the bus to her job downtown each day. The offer of free transit inspired the 24 year-old to register with her new city. She estimates that she saves €23 per month by registering.

Rannar is not alone. More than 10,000 people registered as Tallinn residents in 2013, nearly three times more than registered in 2012. They contribute new annual revenues of about €10 million — almost as much as the lost farebox revenue of €12 million. "If all the registrants were taxpayers," says Deputy Mayor Aas, "then the project costs of free transportation would be covered."

Aas notes that the economics of free transit would be different in other cities. One reason why it works in Tallinn is that the system was highly subsidized to begin with. That's not the case in London, for example, where fares account for 85 percent of public transport revenues. Free fares there would leave a gaping budget hole. "It is easier to waiver the ticket revenue if there's already a large subsidy," Aas says. "The subsidy part used to be 70 percent in Tallinn. Now it's 96 percent."

Can it continue?

Whether that decision was worth it is a question that will take more time to answer. In 2014, researchers hope to gain more insight into free transit's impact on the local economy. And they hope to get more data on mode shifting, as well as how various socioeconomic groups are responding to the change. 

Politically, the big question is whether Tallinn will be able to sustain free transit for the long run — or go the way of Hasselt. Aas says it's possible to keep investing in transit even without farebox revenue. "The first year showed that yes, we can," Aas says. "We have bought new buses. Within five years, we want to replace all buses with modern ones. And one tram line is under renovation, along with the buying of new trams."

As Aas sees it, all this is at least as sustainable as the other services governments spend money on. "Are free education and medicine sustainable?" he says. "Or how sustainable is widening of streets and the construction of new crossroads that will soon be filled with new cars?"

But Andres Harjo, head of the city transportation department, says it's important to remember that price isn't everything. Free rides won't be effective if buses and trams become overcrowded, slow, uncomfortable or unreliable. "The price of a free ride is only one measure to attract people to public transport," Harjo says. "My feeling says that if we are able to guarantee quality, then the number of passengers will slowly and continuously rise."

ALSO IN THIS SERIES

Mixed results from free transit in Tallinn

Oded Cats on research from Tallinn

Free transit in the U.S., for college students (coming Wednesday)



Sunday, January 26, 2014

Read it and rage -- 50 doomiest stories of 2013

50 doomiest stories of 2013
http://read.feedly.com/html?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.desdemonadespair.net%2F2014%2F01%2F50-doomiest-stories-of-2013.html&theme=white

Homo sapiens -- the only species known to have pursued self-extinction with the vigor that most life forms use to resist it.


Saturday, January 25, 2014

Via CoolTools: a guide for preserving local history


Best how-to for life stories 

Oral History Workshop

Jan 23, 2014 01:00 am


When you're 64 wouldn't you like someone to ask you about your life story and then preserve it? When you're 24 wouldn't you like to learn what really happened back in the day? Here are some great tips for interviewing and archiving these stories, including two chapters packed with a hundred great sample questions to ask. Technology makes this easy to do. I've done regular video interviews with my children as they grew up and with my parents and in-laws. One of the smartest things I've done. This book hadn't been published then (and it's the best of a half dozen on the subject), but if I had read it then I would have done a better job. Right behind me, my high-school age son is now capturing oral/visual histories, and he found this book extremely helpful too.

-- KK

The Oral History Workshop
Cynthia Hart, Lisa Samson
2009, 180 pages
$11

Sample Excerpts:

Even in interviewing, though, some silence can be a virtue. Particularly if the interviewee is discussing something difficult, a breath of silence implies, "Tell me more, associate further, give me the links to this experience, fantasy, or anxiety."

So, though in preparing for your interview you'll likely focus on what you'll ask, don't forget about the power of a well-chosen pause.

*

Broad questions have a way of eliciting vague answers. Instead of "Tell me about high school," you might start with a smaller, more specific question: "Who were your best friends in high school?" A "little" question about a childhood game could reveal a big truth about a family dynamic. Aim for a combination of broad and specific questions to get the full story.

*

fish

What insights have you gained about your parents over the years?

*

Begin each recording by identifying the time, place, and names of the participants. This will serve as a journalistic "time stamp."
…
To give audio recordings a visual context, take still photographs of your interviewee (and if possible of the two of you together) at the interview location.

*

Before you finish an interview, ask yourself, "Is there one last question I need to ask in order to achieve what I'd hoped for?" Then ask the interviewee: "Is there anything that you would like to talk about?" or "What have we not discussed that you feel is important for me to know about you and your life?"

*

Describe a typical family meal in your childhood home. What was usually on the menu? Who sat where around the table? Did it matter to you?

What is the best gift you've ever given someone? The best gift you've ever received?

…

If you could take only one last trip, where would you go and with whom? What would you do?

What's the biggest mistake you ever made? What did it teach you?

Who are your three closest friends? How are they different from one another, and why is each so dear to you?

Friday, January 24, 2014

Another "coming soon in Salem"

Here's the solution to underused parking structures:  convert them into places for people to live in instead of storage spots for cars.


We Need to Design Parking Garages With a Car-less Future in Mind

Eric Jaffe, The Atlantic 
The Joni Mitchell song "Big Yellow Taxi" rues the day they paved paradise to put up a parking lot. But on East 13th Street in Manhattan, they're doing the reverse. The New York Post reports that a developer has turned a former Hertz garage into an uber-luxury residential building, complete with rooftop foliage (and, yes, parking spaces for tenants). What's most interesting is that the developers decided not to raze the garage but merely to renovate it:

"It has very good bones," says [Dan Hollander, managing partner of DHA Capital] of the garage. "There are over 10-foot ceilings, good columns and the property is 67 feet wide — that's what really attracted us to it."


There's a growing belief among architects and designers that all urban parking garages should be built with these "good bones," which will allow them to be re-purposed in the future. For a variety of reasons, from higher gas prices to greater densification to better transit options, city residents will continue to drive fewer cars. As a result, we'll eventually require fewer parking lots. The ability to adapt a structure rather than tear it down will save developers time, money, and material waste.

"As the auto culture wanes we're going to have a lot of demolition to do, which is unfortunate," says Tom Fisher, dean of the College of Design at the University of Minnesota. "If we're going to build these [garages] let's design them in a way that they can have alternative uses in the future. With just a few tweaks that's really possible."...


Carless cities and sky cycles
http://read.feedly.com/html?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.resilience.org%2Fstories%2F2014-01-24%2Fcarless-cities-and-sky-cycles&theme=white


Next for Salem: Massive Wave of Retail Store Closings Predicted

Massive Wave of Retail Store Closings Predicted

Krystina Gustafson looks at the coming "tsunami" of store closures as North America transitions to the "next era in retail".  

"Shoppers will likely see an average decrease in overall retail square footage of between one-third and one-half within the next five to 10 years, as a shift to e-commerce brings with it fewer mall visits and a lesser need to keep inventory stocked in-store, said Michael Burden, a principal with Excess Space Retail Services."

Wells Fargo analyst Paul Lejuez believes "it makes more sense for a retailer to have half the number of stores they once thought appropriate, and instead concentrate on a small store network and e-commerce business."

Full Story: A 'tsunami' of store closings expected to hit retail

COMMENTS


PREPARE FOR THE AICP EXAM

Join the thousands of students who have utilized the Planetizen AICP* Exam Preparation Class to prepare for the American Planning Association's AICP* exam.
Starting at $189

Planetizen Courses image ad

PLANETIZEN COURSES

Advance your career with subscription-based online courses tailored to the urban planning profressional.
Starting at $14.95 a month

Book cover of Unsprawl

UNSPRAWL: REMIXING SPACES AS PLACES

Explore visionary, controversial and ultimately successful strategies for building people-centered places.
Starting at $12.95

DVD Cover of The Story of Sprawl

THE STORY OF SPRAWL

See how America changed shape in this collection of historic films that visually document how sprawl evolved.

Thursday, January 23, 2014

EXACTLY! "Saying no for the sake of yes"

Subject: Strong Towns Update for 01/22/2014
Reply-To: Strong Towns <marohn@strongtowns.org>

Saying no for the sake of yes.

Jan 22, 2014 05:00 am | Gracen Johnson


You have to be willing to say no to the bad if you want your city to be built with the good, especially with the development incentives rigged as they are today. Sometimes this can create pro and anti-development factions in your city. A tool to diffuse that animosity is to remember that every time you say no to a proposal, you could be saying yes to something better.
Read More

Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Oncologists call for Medicare for All

> January 20, 2014
> 11:23 AM
> CONTACT: Physicians for a National Health Program
>
> Mark Almberg, communications director, Physicians for a National Health Program, mark@pnhp.org
>
> Oncologists call for Single Payer in Leading Cancer Journal
> Article in leading cancer journal calls on oncologists to support single-payer national health insurance

> WASHINGTON - January 20 - A feature article published this week in the Journal of Oncology Practice contains an evidence-based appeal by two oncologists, including a past president of the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO), for their colleagues to endorse a single-payer health system.
>
> The authors are Dr. Ray Drasga, a longtime community-based oncologist who founded a free clinic in his own community of Crown Point, Ind., and Dr. Lawrence Einhorn, a distinguished professor of medicine at Indiana University Hospital in Indianapolis.
>
> Einhorn is perhaps best known for his pioneering research in the treatment of testicular cancer; his successful treatment of cyclist Lance Armstrong received widespread media attention. His research interests also include tumor oncology and lung cancer.
>
> Einhorn is also past president of ASCO, the largest and most respected oncology society in the world, and has won numerous professional awards for his achievements in clinical cancer research.
>
> "With the costs of cancer care skyrocketing out of control, most people with cancer are burdened not only physically but also financially," said Dr. Drasga, the lead author. "They delay or do not receive care due to their inability to pay.
>
> "The crisis in health care is much more pronounced in cancer due to the high costs of drugs, tests, and procedures," he said. "For example, the cost of a new cancer drug has increased to a median price of $10,000 per month since 2010, and some drugs cost much more.
>
> "The situation is worsening," he said. "We need a fundamental shift in our approach to funding health care in the United States."
>
> The authors ask their fellow oncologists and their society, ASCO, to endorse a single-payer system of national health care insurance. They say they do not believe that the Affordable Care Act, or "Obamacare," will be able to solve the health care crisis that cancer patients face.
>
> The Journal of Oncology Practice is a publication of the American Society of Clinical Oncology. Its focus is on providing oncologists and other oncology professionals with information aimed at enhancing practice efficiency and promoting a high standard for quality of patient care.
>
> ###
> Physicians for a National Health Program is a single issue organization advocating a universal, comprehensive single-payer national health program. PNHP has more than 15,000 members and chapters across the United States

Sunday, January 19, 2014

Query

Why doesn't the post office sell "forever" second-ounce stamps for first-class letters?

Likewise, why no forever stamp for postcards? (Maybe the second-ounce forever stamp could also be the same one for postcards.)

The whole point of the forever stamp was to avoid having to print small-stamp denominations to accommodate rate changes, but the problem persists when you get to a second ounce or try to save money by using postcards; the forever stamp doesn't cut it above one ounce.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-denominated_postage

Phones to Replace Farecards Aboard U.S. Transit Systems [feedly]

Salem needs to implement this in an expanded way, to create a single system that let's the user use a cell phone to pay for or receive credits from others for parking, transit, tolls, and ride shares and even gasoline. 

Anything having to do with mobility should be accessible/payable with this system, which users can add to via their phone cards, but which can accept credits from employers (for using transit, say, preserving parking for others) and public trip reduction programs.  Payment systems accessible via texting are already here.  

What is needed is to stop thinking in silos, with mobility services and services that critically depend on mobility all Balkanized among agencies that don't communicate or even acknowledge each other (schools with massive bus systems and acres of free parking encouraging driving, parking services, bus system, public health workers, etc). 

A Suburb that Makes Walking to School a Priority [feedly]

A Suburb that Makes Walking to School a Priority
http://read.feedly.com/html?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.planetizen.com%2Fnode%2F66959&theme=white