Tuesday, November 23, 2010

Even when the buildings don't actually fall down, LEED is questionable

Turns out that, like so many other things in America since R. Reagan told Americans that the only thing they needed was a sunny optimism, LEED is a lot more about marketing than engineering.

As the proud owners of a $34 million "LEED-Certified" disaster, people in Salem and Marion County should probably be open to the message that it's time to rethink our certifications. Unless builders and architects are willing to offer performance guarantees for how the building will work in practice, any money spent on certifications might just as well be spent on building a corral for the Magic Unicorn that they promised you too.

(I think of this video every day when I see the "LEED" plaque on Courthouse Square -- no doubt the LEED salesmen are insisting that it's a chance in a million for gravity to pull down a building.)

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

I was excited when I first heard about LEED, but am now disenchanted with the whole thing. Pringle Creek Community has won all kinds of awards for its LEED features, touted as a model for sustainable development, etc., but there's nothing there! Am afraid this emperor has no clothes...it's all about high tech (and energy-intensive by the way) consumerism and very little about sensitive use of the earth or community, imho.